Sony beats a $2.6 billion UK class action over PlayStation Store digital prices
Sony just scored a full win in London. The UK’s Competition Appeal Tribunal dismissed a $2.6 billion (£2 billion) class action over PlayStation Store digital prices in its entirety, ruling that the claim failed to show Sony broke competition law (The Game Business, Insider Gaming).
What the claim argued
- The case: Consumer campaigner Alex Neill filed the action in August 2022. It was certified in November 2023 and covered UK buyers of PlayStation digital games and add-on content from August 2016 through February 2026 — about 12.2 million people, according to ICLG.
- The charge: that PlayStation had a “near monopoly” on digital games and add-ons on its own platforms, set strict terms for developers and took a 30% commission that led to “excessive and unfair prices.”
- The lock-in argument: once you own a PlayStation, the lawsuit said, you are trapped in Sony’s store.
Why the tribunal dismissed it
- A wider market: the tribunal said Sony competes in a broader “systems market” with Xbox, Nintendo and PC, and that physical games are still an option, at least for now.
- No duty to open the store: forcing PlayStation to allow third-party storefronts would be expensive, complex and could hurt security, and competition law did not require Sony to do it.
- Prices not proven unfair: Neill did not prove Sony’s margins were excessive, the tribunal said, especially because console makers sell hardware cheaply and recoup the cost on software. It also found no evidence that rival stores would have brought prices down.
What happens next
Sony still faces similar class actions in Australia, the Netherlands and Portugal, which The Game Business says are at an earlier stage. Neill said she was disappointed by the judgment and is considering whether to appeal. ICLG reports the tribunal has scheduled a further hearing in the week of December 14 to consider any application for permission to appeal, and costs.
Koffee take: a closed console store just got a big legal boost in the UK. That is not the last word — other countries still have cases teed up, and an appeal is still on the table.
Filed Nov 17, 2026 ~9:45 AM CT — Sony UK ruling. Sources: The Game Business (Nov 17, 2026), Insider Gaming (Nov 17, 2026), and ICLG (Nov 17, 2026) for the class size, Neill’s statement and the December appeal hearing. Card image: official PlayStation Store artwork, credited to PlayStation (via Insider Gaming).