The Bagelers is bringing kettle-boiled, Chicago-style bagels to Logan Square in late December
Logan Square is getting its own bagel shop. The Bagelers, the Lincoln Park spot known for hand-rolled, kettle-boiled bagels, plans to open a second location in late December at 2415 N. Milwaukee Ave., the former Blazed Bakery space (Block Club Chicago).
What makes it a Chicago bagel
“A Chicago bagel is a little softer and sweeter and less dense than a typical bagel,” owner Sarah Flosi told Block Club. “Kettle-boil is our way.” Block Club says it will be the neighborhood’s only dedicated bagel shop.
What to order
- Jalapeño-cheddar bagel: the shop’s most popular, and a People’s Choice winner at this year’s Chicago Bagel Fest.
- Sandwiches: The Bageler (thick-cut bacon, baked egg, Muenster, chipotle mayo), The Hashy (plus a hash brown and hot honey) and two new ones for Logan Square, with chorizo and pastrami.
- Spreads: garlic-chive and giardiniera cream cheese, with French onion on the way.
A bagel with cream cheese is $3, and sandwiches start at $8.85. Hours will match Lincoln Park: 7 a.m.–3 p.m. weekdays and 8 a.m.–3 p.m. weekends, with seating for 55.
The story behind it
Flosi, an attorney, bought The Bagelers in 2022 and runs it with her brother-in-law and partner Tom Pratl. “Chicago needs family-owned places and we have to keep that alive here,” she said.
Koffee take: a $3 bagel with giardiniera cream cheese is about as Chicago as breakfast gets.
Filed Nov 18, 2026 ~12 PM CT — Midday pass. Sources: Block Club Chicago (Nov 18, 2026). Opening is planned for late December; no exact date yet. Card image: Block Club Chicago.