← Back to Food · Food stories / culture
a thin cracker-crust pizza cut into a grid of small squares on a metal tray, sitting on a dark wood tavern bar beside a cold beer and a stack of cocktail napkins, warm neon beer-sign glow in a cozy neighborhood bar, no logos, no text

The tavern-cut takeover: Chicago’s thin, square-cut pizza is popping up from New York to Fort Worth

Deep dish gets the postcards, but ask a Chicagoan what shows up at the birthday party. Eater reports that tavern-style pizza, the Midwest’s thin, cracker-crisp pie cut into squares, has gone national (Eater).

What makes it tavern-style

  • Thin and crisp. A cracker-like crust, with sauce that leans sweet or spicy depending on where your nostalgia lives.
  • The party cut. Cut into a grid, not triangles, so one pie feeds more people and every square fits on a cocktail napkin.
  • Toppings to the edge. Bradley Shorten of Kim’s Uncle Pizza in west-suburban Westmont told Eater every square should get a little of everything. The tiny corner pieces are the ones “everybody goes for.”

Where it’s spreading

Eater points to openings like Keepers in New York City, One Trick Pony in Fort Worth, Tillie’s Tavern Pizza in Wheat Ridge, Colorado, and Shorten’s La Merna in Washington, D.C. Back home, newer Chicago spots Zarella and Dimmi Dimmi Corner Italian are leaning into the style too. Suburban Chicago transplants Brittany and Brennan Grosvenor sell it at Proof in Portland, Oregon.

Koffee take: it’s nice to see the rest of the country catch up on what Chicago actually eats on a Friday night. Order a large, fight for the corners, and save deep dish for when the relatives visit.

Filed Oct 20, 2026 ~8:45 PM CT — Evening pass. Sources: Eater — The ‘Tavern-Style’ Pizza Takeover (Oct 20, 2026).