← Back to Food · Culture
Eater photo: a chef's tattooed hand dusts spice through a small sieve over a golden seafood vol-au-vent on a white plate at Creepies

Eater Chicago’s 2026 winners: Creepies, Mazor, Bad Butter and a Thai-and-martini double act

Chicago’s year in eating just got its scorecard. Eater Chicago named its 2026 Eater Award winners, and the list reads like a love letter to the city’s own flavors: giardiniera in the mussels, tavern-cut tarte flambé, and a bakery line that never quits.

The winners

  • Best New Restaurant: Creepies. David and Anna Posey’s bistro folds French technique into Chicago classics, with Pernod mussels and fennel giardiniera, a “tavern-style” tarte flambé, Brie gougères and a baguette-infused soft serve.
  • Chef of the Year: Cristian Orozco, Mazor. The Guatemala-born chef opened Mazor in June, bridging Mexican and Guatemalan cooking at friendly prices, like a $9 bluefin tuna tostada with salsa macha.
  • Best New Bakery: Bad Butter. Dan Koester’s Bucktown bakery on West Cortland has had lines out the door since May for focaccia, twice-baked almond croissants and harissa monkey bread.
  • Dish of the Year: puffed grain toast at All Well. The West Loop restaurant from Oriole alums Larry Feldmeier and Noah Sandoval serves it with buckwheat honey butter on its $145 five-course tasting menu.
  • Best New Restaurant and Bar Combo: Crying Tiger and Kitty’s Cosmopolitan Club. Southeast Asian plates upstairs, a velvety 1920s cocktail lounge downstairs.
  • Punch’s Best New Bar: Culebra. A Puerto Rican cocktail bar tucked behind Lonesome Rose in Logan Square.

Pro tip

Eater’s advice for the combo winner: once you’re seated at Crying Tiger, head downstairs to Kitty’s host stand and book your nightcap, because Kitty’s is a tough walk-in. Eater has also mapped every Chicago winner.

Koffee take: a year where a $9 tostada and a $145 tasting menu both make the list is a good year. Start with Bad Butter early, and bring patience.

Filed Nov 11, 2026 ~4:30 PM CT — Afternoon pass. Sources: Eater Chicago — Introducing Chicago’s 2026 Eater Award Winners (Isaiah Reynolds, Brenna Houck, Missy Frederick and Brenda Storch, Nov 10, 2026) · Eater Chicago — winners map. Card image: Kim Kovacik/Eater.